O lado negativo da criatividade: compreensões, determinantes e modelo teórico
The negative side of creativity: understandings, determinants, and theoretical model
Resumo
Tomada tradicionalmente como uma característica positiva e associada a resultados importantes em diferentes contextos, a criatividade tem sido intensamente investigada nas últimas décadas. Mais recentemente, o reconhecimento de que essa característica pode se apresentar sob uma ótica negativa, chamada de criatividade malévola, tem gerado interesse em pesquisadores de diferentes áreas. Os resultados de uma revisão bibliográfica sobre criatividade são apresentados no texto, enfocando sua definição, principais determinantes, modelos teóricos, sua ocorrência no contexto educacional, finalizando com uma reflexão acerca dos principais desafios a serem superados em futuras pesquisas. Trata-se de uma temática ainda não investigada no Brasil.
Palavras-chave: Potencial criativo; Criatividade negativa; Criatividade malévola.
Abstract
Over the past couple of decades, creativity has been intensively studied as a positive characteristic associated with important results in various contexts. Recently, researchers from various fields have observed that this characteristic can also manifest itself in a negative manner, a phenomenon called malevolent creativity, together with negative giftedness. This text presents the results of a bibliographic review on negative creativity and giftedness with a focus on its definition, main determinants, theoretical models, and occurrence in educational settings, along with a reflection on future research challenges to be overcome in future research. It is a topic that has not yet been studied in Brazil.
Keywords: Creative potential; Negative creativity; Malevolent creativity.
Downloads
Referências
AGNOLI, S.; CORAZZA, G. E.; RUNCO, M. A. Estimating creativity with a multiple- measurement approach within scientific and artistic domains. Creativity Research Journal, v. 28, n. 2, p. 171–176, 2016.
AL-MAHDAWI, A. M.; DUTTON, E.; MOHAMMAD, H. A.; BAKHIET, S. F.; MOHAMMAD, N. A.; KHAIR, S.; MADISON, G. Sex differences in malevolent creativity among Sudanese students. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 196, e111724, 2022.
BARBOT, B.; CERDA, K.; TEO, T. Negative ideation in creative problem- solving is task-specific too: evidences from a sample of incarcerated Juveniles. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 38, 100740, 2020.
BARBOT, Baptiste; TINIO, Pablo P. L. Where is the “g” in creativity? A specialization–differentiation hypothesis. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, v. 8, p. 1041, 2015.
BARBOT, Tino; CERDA, Kassandra; TEO, Taralyn. Negative ideation in creative problem-solving is task-specific too: Evidence from a sample of incarcerated juveniles. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 38, 100740, 2020.
BATEY, M.; HUGHES, D. J.; MOSLEY, A.; OWENS, C. E.; FURNHAM, A. Psychopathy and openness-to-experience as predictors of malevolent and benevolent creativity. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 196, e111715, 2022.
BEDU-ADDO, P. K.; MAHAMA, I.; AMOAKO, B. M.; AMOS, P. M.; ANTWI, T. Neglectful Parenting and Personality Traits as Predictors of Malevolent Creativity among Ghanaian Tertiary Education Students. Creative Education, v. 14, p. 232-244, 2023.
Chavez-Eakle, R.A., Eakle, A.J., & Cruz-Fuentes, C. (2012). The multiple relations between creativity and personality. Creativity Research Journal, 24, 76–82; doi: 10.1080/10400419.2012.649233.
CLARK, K.; JAMES, K. Justice and positive and negative creativity. Creativity Research Journal, v. 12, p. 311–320, 1999.
CROPLEY, David H. The dark side of creativity. In RUNCO, M. A.; PRITZKER, S. R. Encyclopedia of creativity. Academic Press, 2011. p. 351-357.
CROPLEY, David H.; CROPLEY, A. J. Malevolent Creativity: Past, Present and Future. In KAUFMAN, J. C.; STERNBERG, R. J. Cambridge Handbook of Creativity. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2019. p. 677-690.
CROPLEY, David H. The dark side of creativity: a differentiated model. In D. H. CROPLEY; A. J. CROPLEY; J. C. KAUFMAN; M. A. RUNCO. The dark side of creativity. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010. p. 360–373
CROPLEY, David H., KAUFMAN, James C.; WHITE, Arielle E.; CHIERA, Belinda A. Layperson perceptions of malevolent creativity: the good, the bad, and the ambiguous. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, v. 8, n. 4, p. 400-412, 2014.
CROPLEY, David H.; KAUFMAN, James C.; CROPLEY, Arthur J. Malevolent creativity: A functional model of creativity in terrorism and crime. Creativity Research Journal, v. 20, 105e115, 2008.
d'Amato, A. L., Theobald, E., Scott, M. N., Linnell, A. E., Elson, J. S., & Hunter, S. T. (2025). Harnessing harm: Artificial intelligence’s role in the amplification of malevolent creativity and innovation. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts. Advance online publication.
DAN, W.; DIANHUI, W.; WENFENG, C. The relationship between adolescents’ resilience and their malevolent creative behaviors. Acta Psychologica Sinica, v. 54, n. 2, p. 154-167, 2021.
DOU, X.; DOU, X.; JIA, L. Interactive association of negative creative thinking and malevolent creative thinking. Frontiers in Psychology, v. 13, e9939672, 2022.
DU, X., ZHAO, Y.; ZHANG, K. The influence of group categorization and common ingroup identity on malevolent creativity, benevolent creativity, and neutral creativity. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 54, 101686, 2024.
DUMAS, D.G.; STRICKLAND, A.L. From book to bludgeon: A closer look at unsolicited malevolent responses on the alternate uses task. Creativity Research Journal, v. 30, p. 439–450, 2018.
FARIAS, E. S.; BONFÁ-ARAUJO, B.; NAKANO, T. C., CAMPOS, C. R. Malevolent Creativity Behavior Scale-Brazilian Portuguese: Cross-Cultural Adaptation and Psychometric Properties. Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 59, n. 2, p. 1-8, 2025.
FLACH, L. O jeitinho brasileiro: analisando suas características e influências nas práticas oerganizacionais. Revista Gestão e Planejamento, v. 12, n. 3, p. 499-514, 2012.
FOUSIANI, K.; XU, S.; VAN PROOIJEN, J.-W. Leaders' power construal influences malevolent creativity: The mediating role of organizational conspiracy beliefs. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, v. 98, e70005, 2025.
FU, H.; ZHANG, Z. The relationship between Honesty-Humility and malevolent creativity: Sequential mediation models with prosocial moral emotional traits and prosocial tendencies. Current Psychology, v. 43, p. 7424–7436, 2024.
GAO, Z.; CHENG, L.; LI, J.; CHEN, Q.; HAO, N. The dark side of creativity: Neural correlates of malevolent creative idea generation. Neuropsychologia, v. 167, e108164, 2022.
GAO, Z. N.; QIAO, X. N.; LU, K.; WANG, X.; HAO, N. Dynamic amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation links dark personalities to malevolent creative behavior. Brain and Cognition, v. 183, 106245, 2025.
GAZOS, A.; MADEIRA, A.; PLATTNER, G.; ROLLER, T.; BUSCHER, C. New and emerging perspectives for technology assessment: Malevolent creativity and civil security. Journal for Technology assessment in theory and practice, v. 33, n. 2, p. 9-15, 2024.
GENG, Y.; SHI, Y.; HU, W.; JIN, W.; ZHANG, Y.; ZHAN, T. Fight Injustice with Darkness: The Effect of Early Life Adversity on Malevolent Creativity Behavior. Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 58, n. 2, p. 279-296, 2024.
HAMEED, I. Crafting harm: how Machiavellianism, competitive worldview, and supervisor bottom-line mentality fuel malevolent creativity? Journal of Economics and Administrative Sciences, ahead of print, 2025.
HAO, N.; QIAO, X.; CHENG, R.; LU, K.; TANG, M.; RUNCO, M. A. Approach motivational orientation enhances malevolent creativity. Acta Psicológica, v. 203, e10295, 2020.
HUDSON, L. Frames of mind: Ability, perception and self-perception in the arts and sciences. W. W. Norton, 1968.
HUNTER, S. T.; WALTERS, K.; NGUYEN, T.; MANNING, C.; MILLER, S. Malevolent Creativity and Malevolent Innovation: A Critical but Tenuous Linkage. Creativity Research Journal, v. 34, n. 2, p. 123-144, 2021.
JAMES, K.; CLARK, K.; CROPANZANO, R. Positive and negative creativity in groups, institutions, and organizations: A model and theoretical extension. Creativity Research Journal, v. 12 n. 3, p. 211-226, 1999.
JIA, X.; WANG, Q.; LIN, L. The Relationship Between Childhood Neglect and Malevolent Creativity: The Mediating Effect of the Dark Triad Personality. Frontiers in Psychology, v. 11, 613695, 2020.
JONASON, P.K.; RICHARDSON, E.N.; POTTER, L. Self-reported creative ability and the dark triad traits: An exploratory study. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, v. 9, 488–494, 2015.
KAPOOR, H. The creative side of the dark triad. Creativity Research Journal, v. 27, p. 58–67, 2015.
KAPPOR, H. Sex differences and similarities in negative creativity. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 142, p. 238-241, 2019.
KAPPOR, H.; KAUFMAN, J. C. The evil within the AMORAL model of dark creativity. Theory & Psychology, v. 32, n. 3, p. 467-490, 2022.
KAPOOR, H.; KHAN, A. The Measurement of Negative Creativity: Metrics and Relationships. Creativity Research Journal, v. 28, n. 4, p. 407-416, 2016.
KAPOOR, H.; MAHADESHWAR, H.; REZAEI, S.; REITER-PALMON, R.; KAUFMAN, J. C. The Ties That Bind: Low Morals, High Deception, and Dark Creativity. Creativity Research Journal, p. 1–20, 2024.
KAPOOR, H.; TAGAT, A.; CROPLEY, D. H. Fifty shades of creativity: case studies of malevolent creativity in arts, science, and technology. In REISMAN, F. Creativity in arts, science, and technology. KIE Conference Publications, 2016. p. 25-45.
KAPPOR, H.; KHAN, A. Deceptively yours: valence-based creativity and deception. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 23, p. 199-206, 2017.
LEBUDA, I.; FIGURA, B.; KARWOWSKI, M. Creativity and the dark triad: a meta-analysis. Journal of Research in Personality, v. 92, e104088, 2021.
LEE, S. A.; DOW, G. T. Malevolent creativity: Does personality influence malicious divergent thinking? Creativity Research Journal, v. 23, p. 3–82, 2011.
LI, W.; ZHANG, L.; QIN, Z.; CHEN, J.; LIU, C. Childhood Trauma and Malevolent Creativity in Chinese College Students: Moderated Mediation by Psychological Resilience and Aggression. Journal of Intelligence, v. 10, n. 97, 2022.
LIU, C.; LI, L.; GONG, Z. Development and Testing of the Cyber Malevolent Creativity Behavior Scale. Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 58, p. 478-490, 2024.
MALIK, O. F.; SHAHZAD, A.; WAHEED, A.; YOUSAF, Z. Abusive supervision as a trigger of malevolent creativity: do the Light Triad traits matter? Leadership & Organization Development Journal, v. 41, n. 8, p. 1119-1137, 2020.
MESHKOVA, N. V.; BOCHKOVA, M. N.; KRAVTSOV, O. G. Malevolent Creativity and Personal Features of Young People in Different Socio-Political Conditions: Relationship and Interaction. Lomonosov Psychology Journal, v. 47, n. 1, p. 88-105, 2024.
MITCHELL, Kevin, S.; REITER-PALMON, Roni. Malevolent creativity: personality, process, and the larger creativity field. In KAPPOR, Hansika; KAUFMAN, James C. Creativity, and morality. London: Elsevier, 2022. p. 49-69.
MOTTA, F. C. P.; ALCADIPANI, R. Jeitinho brasileiro, índole social e competição. Revista de Administração de Empresas, v. 39, n. 1, p. 6-12, 1999.
NGUYEN, T. L.; D’AMATO, A. L.’ MILLER, S. R.’ HUNTER, S. T. Malevolent Creativity as Parochial Altruism? Examining the Intergroup Bases of New and Harmful Ideas. Creativity Research Journal, v. 37, n. 1, p. 104–119, 2023.
NGUYEN, T. L.; WALTERS, K. N.; D’AMATO, A. L.; MILLER, S. R.; HUNTER, S. T. Target Personification Influences the Positive Emotional Link Between Generating and Implementing Malevolently Creative Ideas. Creativity Research Journal, v. 36, n. 1, p. 42–57, 2022.
OLIVEIRA, K. S.; NAKANO, T. C; WECHSLER, S. M. Criatividade e saúde mental: uma revisão da produção científica na última década. Temas em Psicologia, v. 24, n. 4, p. 1493-1506, 2016.
PALMER, C.; KRAUS, S.; RIBEIRO-SORIANO, D. Exploring dark creativity: the role of power in an unethical marketing task. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja, v. 33, n. 1, p. 145-159, 2020.
PALMER C., KRAUS S.; RIBEIRO-SORIANO D. Exploring dark creativity: The role of power in an unethical marketing task. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja, v. 33, n. 1, p. 145–159, 2020.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; FINK, A.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I. Motivational factors in the typical display of humor and creative potential: the case of malevolent creativity. Frontiers in Psychology, v. 11, n. 1213, 2020.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; FINK, A.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I. Creative, antagonistic, and angry? Exploring the roots of malevolent creativity with a real- world idea generation task. The Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 55, n. 3, p. 710–722, 2021a.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; FINK, A.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I. Failure to reappraise: Malevolent creativity is linked to revenge ideation and impaired reappraisal inventiveness in the face of stressful, anger-eliciting events. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, v. 34, n. 4, p. 437-449, 2021b.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; FINK, A.; ROMINGER, C.; SAZBÓ, E. Enjoying others’ distress and indifferent to threat? Changes in prefrontal-posterior coupling during social-emotional processing are linked to malevolent creativity. Brain and Cognition, v. 163, e105913, 2022.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I.; FINK, A. Antisocial schizotypy is linked to malevolent creativity. Creativity Research Journal, v. 34, n. 3, p. 355-367, 2022.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I.; FINK, A. Women and men have a similar potential for malevolent creativity – But their underlying brain mechanisms are different. Brain Research, v. 1801, e148201, 2023a.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; FINK, A.; ROMINGER, C.; PAPOUSEK, I. Failure to reappraise: Malevolent creativity is linked to revenge ideation and impaired reappraisal inventiveness in the face of stressful, anger-eliciting events. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, v. 34, n. 4, p. 437–449, 2021c.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; ROMINGER, C.; FINK, A. Depressive symptoms are positively linked to malevolent creativity: a novel perspective on the maladaptive nature of revenge ideation. The Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 0, n. 0, p. 1-12, 2023b.
PERCHTOLD-STEFAN, C. M.; SZABÓ, E.; ROMINGER, C.; FINK, A.; OPRIS, L.; PATAKY, N. Criminal Genius or Everyday Villain? A Comparison of Malevolent Creativity Among Prisoners, Police Officers, and the General Population. Journal of Creative Behavior, v. 58, p. 676-695, 2024.
PILATI, R.; MILFONT, T. L.; FERREIRA, M. C.; PORTO, J. B.; FISCHER, R. (Brazilian jeitinho: understanding and explaining an indigenous psychological construct. Interamerican Journal of Psychology, v. 45, n. 1, p. 27-36, 2011.
PRADO, A. M. O jeitinho brasileiro: uma revisão bibliográfica. Horizonte Científico, v. 10, n. 1, p. 1–22, 2016.
RHODES, M. An analysis of creativity. Phi Delta Kappan, v. 42, n. 7), p. 305–310, 1961.
RUNCO, M. A.; JAEGER, G. J. The standard definition of creativity. Creativity Research Journal, v. 24, n. 1, p. 92–96, 2012.
SHI, Zifu; ZHOU, Zhihao, TIAN, Lan; ZHU, Yufan, LIU, Chengzhen; XU, Lei. What causes malevolent creative people to engage in malevolent behaviors? Mediating role of moral disengagement and moderating effects of conscience. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 49, n. 101329, 2023.
SILVA, D.; JUNÇA-SILVA, A.; PINHEIRO, P. Folie à deux? How Mavericks shape the relationship between the dark triad and negative deviant behaviors through malevolent creativity. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 233, e112877, p. 1-6, 2025.
STERNBERG, Robert J. ACCEL: a new model for identifying the gifted. Roeper Review, v. 39, n. 3, p. 152-169, 2017.
STERNBERG, Robert J. the vexing problem of dark giftedness. Gifted Education International, v. 39, n. 3, p. 265-285, 2023b.
STERNBERG, Robert J. Toxic giftedness. Roeper Review, v. 45, n. 1, p. 61-73, 2023a.
SZABÓ, Eniko; KORMENDI, Attila; KURUCZ, Gyozo; CROPLEY, David; OLAJOS, Timea; PATAKY, Nóra. Personality traits as predictors of malevolent creative ideation in offenders. Behavioral Sciences, v. 12, p. 242, 2022.
WACHELKE, J.; PRADO, A. M. A ideologia do jeitinho brasileiro. Psicologia e Saber Social, v. 6, n. 2, p. 146-162, 2017.
WANG, Y.; ZHANG, K.; XU, F.; ZONG, Y.; CHEN, L.; LI, W. The effect of justice sensitivity on malevolent creativity: the mediating role of anger and the moderating role of emotion regulation strategies. BMC Psychology, v. 12, 265, 2024.
WU, J.; MA, F.; LIU, J.; JIAO, L. The effects of different types of social exclusion on malevolent creativity: The role of self-construal. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 57, 101837, p. 1-12, 2025.
WU, J.; RAO, X.; LIU, J.; YOU, S.; CAO, Y.; JIAO, L. The impact of social exclusion on malevolent creativity: The mediating role of prosocial motivation. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 2024.
XU, X.; ZHAO, J.; XIA, M.; PANG, W. I can, but I won't: Authentic people generate more malevolently creative ideas, but are less likely to implement them in daily life. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 170, e110431, 2021.
XU, X.; XIA, M.; PANG, W. Do all roads lead to Rome? Authenticity, openness to experience, and risk-taking relate to general and malevolent creativity differently. Current Psychology, 2022.
YANG, B.; LI, H. how multicultural experiences influence malevolent creativity. Psychological Reports, 2024.
YU, L.; QIAO, X.; HAO, N. Intergroup threat stimulates malevolent creative idea generation. Motivation and Emotion, v. 48, p. 531–548, 2024.
ZHANG, M.; GUO, H.; GONG, Z. The Effect of Anger Rumination on Malevolent Creativity: The Mediating Role of Aggression and the Moderating Role of Mindfulness. Psychological Reports, 0(0), 2025.
ZHANG, W.; QIN, Z.; CHEN, J.; LIU, C. Childhood Trauma and Malevolent Creativity in Chinese College Students: Moderated Mediation by Psychological Resilience and Aggression. Journal of Intelligence, v. 10, n. 97, 2022.
ZHANG, W.; LIANG, Q.; QIAO, X.; HAO, N. Unfairness brings malice: Malevolent creativity is modulated by perceived unfairness of others. Thinking Skills and Creativity, v. 53, 101586, 2024.
ZHANG, J.; LU, J.; GE, J.; LI, S.; LIANG, X. Managing malice in negative environments: the mediating effect of coping styles on the relationship between negative sense of place and malevolent creativity among Chinese high school students. BMC Psychology, v. 13, n. 35, 2025.
ZHAO, J.; XU, X.; PANG, W. When do creative people engage in malevolent behaviors? The moderating role of moral reasoning. Personality and Individual Differences, v. 186, e111386, 2022.
ZHOU, J.; ZHAO, B.; LI, Y. A network meta-analysis of factors influencing malevolent creativity. Social Behavior and Personality: an international journal, v. 52, n. 4, pp. 1-18, 2024.
